Another piece of regional Australia’s community life has fallen victim to the great Australian obsession with eliminating risk.
The demolition derby will be missing from next year’s Armidale Show, not because people have stopped enjoying watching cars smash into each other, but because changes to insurance requirements have made it unviable.
And there goes another tradition.
Nobody is suggesting demolition derbies are without danger. That’s rather the point. People go to watch cars crash, not to admire their parking skills. But there’s a difference between managing risk sensibly and making an activity so difficult or expensive to insure that it simply disappears.
It’s a distinction the insurance industry, reeling from the burden of climate related disasters, are increasingly failing to make.
Across regional Australia, agricultural shows, festivals, sporting competitions and community celebrations depend on volunteers willing to give their time to create something enjoyable for everyone else. The vast, vast, vast majority of these events are run without incident.
Those volunteers are already dealing with fundraising, sponsorship, permits, regulations, equipment, facilities and the increasingly thankless task of organising anything in an age when everyone has an opinion and social media gives them somewhere to express it.
Now add insurance premiums, liability assessments and ever-expanding safety requirements. In Tamworth, a series of small and volunteer run organisations have also been dealing with a first aid company – required by insurers or regulation in most cases – who has allegedly been fraudulently taking their money and not showing up.
At some point, the sensible decision becomes not to bother.
And that’s a terrible outcome for communities.
We need public liability insurance. We need appropriate safety standards. Nobody wants volunteers exposed to financial ruin because something goes wrong, or spectators unnecessarily placed in danger.
But surely the purpose of insurance is to enable activities to happen safely, not to make them impossible.
The problem extends well beyond community events.
Last week a parliamentary inquiry handed down their report into NSW’s Emergency Services Levy, the tax added to insurance premiums to help fund our firefighters and emergency services.
The inquiry found the current system needs replacing, but couldn’t agree on which of the five alternatives proposed by NSW Treasury should take its place.
Meanwhile, the levy adds an average 18 per cent to home insurance premiums and 34 per cent to premiums for businesses, farms and other non-residential properties.
Think about that. We’re making insurance more expensive to fund the very emergency services people might need when disaster strikes.
It’s a ridiculous contradiction, particularly when governments simultaneously encourage everyone to be adequately insured.
And it illustrates the broader problem. We keep adding costs and obligations to insurance without properly considering the cumulative consequences.
For community organisations operating on shoestring budgets, every additional expense matters. Every new requirement means another volunteer must take responsibility for something. Every increase in liability makes another committee member wonder whether the personal risk is worth it.
Eventually, the event disappears, and with it the visitors, economic activity, community pride and opportunities for people to come together.
We need a better solution.
Governments should work with insurers, councils and community organisations to develop affordable, fit-for-purpose insurance arrangements for not-for-profit events. State-backed group insurance schemes, shared coverage through peak organisations and targeted support for higher-risk activities all deserve serious consideration.
Safety requirements should be proportionate to actual risks, rather than designed around the increasingly unrealistic expectation that nothing can ever go wrong.
And volunteers should be supported by clear, practical standards, not buried under administrative obligations better suited to multinational corporations.
There will always be some activities that are too dangerous to justify. But that decision should be based on genuine risk, not simply whether an insurer is willing to provide affordable coverage.
Regional communities have spent generations building the shows, festivals and traditions that make our towns worth living in.
We shouldn’t need a team of lawyers, a risk consultant and an insurance broker to keep them alive.
If we continue down this path, we’ll eventually achieve the safest possible community event.
One that never happens.
End Rant.

Dr RK (Kath) Crosby is the CEO of research and strategy company KORE CSR, former strategist for the Australian Democrats, and holds a PhD in political behaviour. She is also a well known migraine and health advocate, and the Publisher of New England Times and North Coast Times.
All opinion and comment on New England Times Engage is the opinion of the writer and not New England Times.
Got something on your mind? Go on then, engage. Submit your opinion piece, letter to the editor, or Quick Word now.
