Posted inFeatured, Opinion, Political, Regulars

Denise’s Desk: We don’t elect a president. So why does our political media pretend we do?

We live in a parliamentary democracy, but anyone following Australian political reporting could be forgiven for thinking we elect a president every three years.

Is Anthony Albanese popular? Is he losing authority? Is his leadership under threat? These questions dominate coverage, too often displacing examination of what governments do, what oppositions propose and how their policies affect Australians.

We do not directly elect a prime minister. We elect representatives, and government is formed by the party or coalition commanding the confidence of the House of Representatives. The prime minister leads a collective institution, accountable to parliament and ultimately the people.

Leadership matters. Character, judgment, integrity and communication deserve scrutiny. But the obsession with personality increasingly crowds out policy.

A fall in personal approval generates days of headlines and leadership speculation. Competing policies on housing, taxation, education and health rarely receive equivalent attention.

The preferred prime minister question invites Australians to choose between two individuals as though casting a presidential ballot. It measures perceptions of leadership, but tells us little about policy quality or government performance. No voter will choose between those names on a national ballot.

Much political reporting resembles sports commentary: winners, losers, tactical errors and speculation about the next contest. Policies are assessed for political advantage, changed positions become backflips and disagreements become crises.

Consider the Albanese Government’s redesign of the Stage 3 tax cuts to provide greater relief to low- and middle-income earners facing cost-of-living pressures. Much of the debate centred on broken promises rather than the revised policy’s merits.

The decision to retain Sydney and Melbourne’s historic Victoria Barracks sites in public ownership offered another example. Heritage and community benefits risked being overshadowed by the framing of a political retreat.

Reversing commitments deserves scrutiny. But listening, considering evidence and changing proposals are also part of democratic government. If responding to public concerns automatically signifies weakness, what incentive are we giving governments to listen? Surely the central question is whether the eventual decision benefits the community.

Government extends beyond its leader. Ministers carry responsibilities, cabinets make collective decisions, committees examine legislation and local members represent communities. Parties can change leaders without an election.

Education reform can involve years of consultation with teachers, unions, parents, researchers and education authorities, alongside intergovernmental negotiations and curriculum changes. Yet coverage often reduces it to a political win or loss.

Health, infrastructure, taxation and housing receive similar treatment. The public deserves to know what problem a policy addresses, how it works, what it costs and whether evidence supports it.

Personality-driven reporting also lets oppositions and minor parties escape scrutiny.

Coverage of One Nation’s polling rise concentrates on Pauline Hanson’s popularity, declining Coalition support and implications for the major parties. More consequential questions concern what One Nation proposes and how it would work.

Its commitment to negative net overseas migration for three years includes reducing the temporary migrant population by around 750,000. Economists and industry leaders warn that cuts of this scale could damage growth, worsen labour shortages and potentially cause recession. Regional agriculture, health, aged care and education could face substantial consequences.

Hanson argues that lower migration would ease pressure on housing and services. That deserves examination alongside the economic costs, workforce implications and supporting evidence. Some reporting addresses these concerns, but sustained policy scrutiny matters more than another popularity story.

The same standard must apply to Labor, the Coalition, the Greens and independents. Journalism must explain what voters are turning towards, testing promises, costs and evidence so slogans and anger cannot substitute for credible government.

American political culture encourages this distortion. Presidential campaigns centre on individuals competing for one executive office. Australia elects a parliament, yet our coverage increasingly adopts American assumptions.

Where does that leave the local member whom voters actually elect? Regional representatives must understand communities, advocate for services and ensure regional voices are heard. Their records, qualifications and commitments deserve attention beyond their association with a party leader.

The consequences reach beyond headlines. Personality contests encourage spectatorship: cheer one side, condemn the other and await another poll. Education, health care, housing, wages, taxation and services struggle for attention.

Cynicism follows when every decision becomes manoeuvring, every compromise weakness and every policy change humiliation.

Parties share responsibility. Presidential-style campaigning simplifies messages around recognisable leaders. Journalists should do more than reproduce the drama constructed for them.

Polls and leadership analysis have a legitimate place. The task is restoring balance: examine announcements for practical consequences, question politicians rigorously about policies and judge changes by whether they improve outcomes.

That would produce a better-informed electorate and more substantial debate.

Our parliamentary institutions make government about more than one individual. Political journalism should reflect that.

We elect a parliament, from which a government is formed. Perhaps reporting should start treating us like citizens of a parliamentary democracy rather than spectators at a presidential popularity contest.


All opinion and comment on New England Times Engage is the opinion of the writer and not New England Times.

Got something on your mind? Go on then, engage. Submit your opinion piece, letter to the editor, or Quick Word now.

Share

Leave a comment

Engage respectfully! Posting defamatory or offensive content may get you banned. See our full Terms of Engagement for details.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *